The world’s most populous countries, India and China are certainly headed for an all out war! In today’s post, I will attempt to explain why I think so and also explain a little of the historical context that has led to this point.
Sharing a 3500km long border separated by the Himalayan Mountain Range, Both India and China arrived on the World stage as fully independent entities after 1950. India had shaken off British occupation and declared itself a Republic while the Communists had finally united China into a unified republic again after a period of almost 100 years in the wilderness. Both countries were woefully underdeveloped and most certainly not in a position to defend their territory as effectively as the colonial masters had done. The potential for conflict always existed due to the differing perceptions on the Borders drawn by the departing Colonial Powers however the presence of the Himalayan Range and the lack of technology and resources at the time did serve as a deterrent. Not enough though, ‘cos the 2 countries did go to war in 1962 that ended in a humiliating defeat for India. india lost over 4200 soldiers and 38000 sq kms of territory in a swift war that ended as soon as it began! Since then, the Chinese have popped up intermittently laying claim to more and more Territory on the Indian side. In the last few years since Modi became PM, the Chinese have become emboldened and begun more regular incursions as they take on a more aggressive India. 2018 saw the Doklam incident, in 2019, the Indian Army discovered 26 Patrolling Points (PP) in Ladakh have been lost to the Chinese and in 2020, the 2 soldiers on both sides came to blows killing 20 soldiers on each side. Chinese have never just picked up their guns and gone to war! That has not happened in recent history. Every war is preceded by an increasing frequency of small scale incursions and carefully planned “salami slicing” – Monthly, then weekly and then followed up with an all out war. They are carefully shaping the border in preparation for maximum impact in case of a war. The average frequency of Chinese incursions has gone up from about once in 4 years before 2014 to weekly in 2018 to almost daily now! This is certainly the first indicator that China is preparing for a full blown war!
2020-Current
The Pangong Lake is a high-altitude endorheic Lake split between India and China. Roughly 20% of the lake is on the Ladakh(Indian) side while 80% of the Lake falls within Chinese Territory. Before 2020, Indian troops would regularly patrol upto a point called Finger 8/9 on the Lake (see Map and Terrain Photo below). On 5 May 2020 however, Indian Troops on Patrol were stopped at Finger 4 by Chinese Troops. The Indians discovered that in the Winter season of the previous year when Patrols had not happened, the Chinese had built substantial infrastructure like pucca roads and even Tent Camps all the way upto Finger 4. In these terrifying heights of 5kms+, It is typical to stop patrolling in the winter months of 7/8 months/year. All patrols stop around Nov and troops on both sides withdraw to their winter posts and resume patrolling when the snows begin thawing around April/May. The Chinese had used this period to build substantial infrastructure between Fingers 9 and upto Finger 4. On 5 May, the troops on both sides got into a violent confrontation for the first time since Doklam in 2018.
In late May 2020, the 2 sides clashed in Galwan when Indian troops attempted to stop a Chinese Party of engineers from upgrading infrastructure in the Valley. It was all out melee warfare (since use of arms is prohibited based on a 1996 treaty), throwing Rocks and soldiers off cliffs. Over 20 Indian troops lost their lives in the ensuing melee. On 30 August, Indian Troops fired shots at the Chinese for the first time since 1972, ratcheting up tensions. On 7th September shots were fired from both sides in Hot Springs(Gogra) and Depsang sectors. In the Depsang area, Satellite photos revealed that Chinese had managed to build up huge radar and accomodation facilities within 500m of a tactically critical PP potentially allowing them to cut off traffic on the sensitive DBO -Shyok access road and thus threaten Indian occupation of Siachen Glacier and Depsang Plains. Many Twitter accounts were barred in India for 3 months for posting these explosive pictures! The year before that, the last Chinese post was 23kms behind this sensitive Y-junction! The Indians had been caught napping and it was embarassing politically for the ruling dispensation in India which had made loud noises about putting China in its place!
It was not like the Chinese were sitting quietly on other fronts. 2000kms away, the Chinese had rapidly built up infrastructure in the Doklam/Sikkim area. Satellite maps revealed, that after being blocked by Indian Troops at Doklam, the Chinese had simply bypassed the Doklam area to build access roads upto Gyemochen area. When the Indians withdrew from the Doklam area temporarily, the Chinese returned in force to build further roads in the area. This sector is crucial as it overlooks the Siliguri Corridor or “Chickens-Neck” – a mere 17km wide Corridor that links the disputed North Eastern states to the rest of India. The Chinese also upgraded infrastructure across the border front here from Siliguri to Arunachal (which the Chinese call Zangnan province) and built & settled 2 dozen villages deep inside what Indians claim as their territory in Arunachal/Zangnan.
In summary, the entire border/LAC is disputed but the uneasy calm that existed for over 60 years has been shattered and the 2 countries are most certainly drifting towards war!
Why War is likely
The first reason why I see India and China heading for all out war is that the foundational Basis of what the Chinese see as necessary for a healthy relationship has eroded ever since Modi has come to power. For the Chinese, the “One China Policy” is sacrosanct – this includes Taiwan and Tibet which have been a continuous part of the various Chinese Kingdoms since the 7th century at the least. Even the current American administration and European countries have tiptoed around this issue as they understand that it is a sensitive no-go area for the Chinese. The Modi Govt otoh drifted away from the old Indian policy and moved towards virtually recognising Taiwan. Taiwan has opened “Trade Centers” -virtually consulates in Delhi, Chennai and most recent one in Mumbai. Another is expected to be opened in Bangalore very soon. Further, the 3 Indian service chiefs, Admiral Karambir Singh(Navy), General M M Naravane(Army) and Chief of Air Staff R K S Bhadauria visited Taiwan to participate in a Indo-Pacific Security Dialogue. China is understandably upset about this Power Play by India.
Another reason is the increasing “power play” in the South China Sea – an area that China sees as its “sphere of influence”. The Indian Navy sent in Naval assets to participate in Joint Exercises with the Phillipines Navy. A third rate, brown water force like the Indian Navy is in no position to fight a war in the Malacca Straits let alone the South China Sea if it ever comes to that. So this was a wholly unnecessary and ultimately pointless needling of China that understandably got the Chinese upset. Seeing the tone of reporting in the tightly controlled Chinese media gives an understanding of the level of fury in the Chinese establishment at what they see as Indians acting too big for their boots! I have seen charming terms like “Running Dog of American Imperialism” being used to describe Modi’s India in the mainstream Chinese press. Charming indeed!
Speaking of “Running dog”, Modi also tried to shore up his side by cosying up to the Americans and signing a deal that effectively allows the QUAD alliance to service and replenish their ships at Indian Ports. While closer relations with the US are certainly desirable, the timing and the choice of language used to communicate this deal would have ruffled many feathers in China. In the pre-Modi era, India has signed similar deals with European countries like France for eg. But we certainly didnt see the jingoism we saw with the QUAD deals.
Modi and Xi have not had an official meeting for ages. The latest meeting was on the sidelines of BRICS in south Africa but the 2 sides dont even agree on who initiated the meeting and what was discussed! It is clear that positions on both sides has hardened and the countries are moving towards a 2 front war with India on one side and China-Pak on the other. A war that Modi knows he will lose which he cannot afford in a year that India goes to elections!
This difference in perceptions is primarily driven by the Maps left behind by British which they unilaterally redrew in 1870 to show Territory that they did not and indeed could not control within their British-Indian empire. The Chinese see this as taking back all the territory to the East of the Ladakh Range that is rightfully theirs. As the newest superpower on the world stage, the Chinese feel confident about taking back these territories that they had traditionally held before the British arrival. The Chinese WILL NOT STOP this salami slicing or outright war until they have pushed the line here back to the Ladakh Range as well as take back Zangnan which India calls Arunachal Pradesh. Which effectively means that India would lose another 40000 sq km of territory in Ladakh alone plus the Chinese claim line in South Tibet which would push the border to Dibrugarh!
I have written a detailed historical perspective on Ladakh and Arunachal/Zangnan issues in separate post here. In part 2 of this series tomorrow, I will discuss in detail my thoughts on how this war will be fought and the implications thereof. Thanks for reading!
Like what you read? You can support my work with a small contribution. Scan the image or go to buymeacoffee.com/KaleshiBua to make your contribution.
Comments
Post a Comment